What is JotForm?
JotForm is a free online form builder which helps you create online forms without writing a single line of code. No sign-up required.
At JotForm, we want to make sure that you’re getting the online form builder help that you need. Our friendly customer support team is available 24/7.
We believe that if one user has a question, there could be more users who may have the same question. This is why many of our support forum threads are public and available to be searched and viewed. If you’d like help immediately, feel free to search for a similar question, or submit your question or concern.
Required Signature field able to accept only a dot input outside the signature plateAsked by thebrucecook on April 19, 2013 at 04:53 PM
Not sure if you are aware of this, but I just added the signature box as a required field on one of my forms. After receiving a few forms with a png signature file attached, I received one without an attachment. I was confused how this could happen since it is a required field on the form, so I played around with the form and discovered you could simply click your mouse once within the box boundries, hit the submit button and the form would accept the submission without a signature and without a png file attached.
Not that big of problem on my particular form, but might be for an important legal form. Thought you'd like to know.
My Forms required field problem png
Thank you for this information. I was able to duplicate what you just described.
When I did this (please refer to image below), I was able to submit your form. And in the submissions page, the submissions appears like it is empty (can't find that small dot)
I will elevate this to our next level support so that it can addressed to immediately.
We will notify you once an update is available.
We will open a feature request to detect "too small signatures" but I think this is one of those issues that needs to be manually checked by you. The client can just draw a line or a stickman. You should look at the submissions and if the signature does not look right delete the submission.
I am in the hospitality business and customer service is a priority. I don't think making my customer resign a form multiple times enhances that. (That sounds like a government solution not a private enterprise solution!!) Let's find a way to make this work correctly the first time so myr customers are not inconvenienced and your customers (me) are not inconvenienced.
Thanks for your reply. This is already in the feature request list, FYI.
So I played around with the form and discovered you could simply click your mouse once within the box boundries, hit the submit button and the form would accept the submission without a signature and without a png file attached.
Let me also add my point of view, actually the user can easily bypass the signature field if they tend to. Also, why would a user write dots or a non-signature if they'll submit a legal information? I don't mean to be indecent but this is more of taken cared by you other than making an automation to check it's content. Signature is important so it needs a little time for a manual review. If the user doesn't write a signature, then I guess he doesn't deserved a good response?
Here's my test so far, writing valid signatures outside the box isn't a problem unless you intentionally write dots.
We'll wait your feedback. Thank you!
Substitute the word "customer" for the word "user." All my potential
customers, who keep me, and by extension, you in business, deserve a good
Bruce Cook, CPA
PO Box 341312
Austin, TX 78734
Lake Travis Tree Lodge
Discount Business Brokers USA
Third Rock Tours
*The best way to cheer yourself up it to try to cheer somebody else up.
Has anyone else, preferrable someone who knows what customer service means, found a work around for this problem?
Jotform's suggestion that my "users" (i.e. my customers) don't deserve a response if they don't sign the form correctly isn't workable in the real world. I'm running a small bed and breakfast, so these "users" are my guests and I cannot afford to drive them away because they won't conform to jotform.
I changed the instructions for the box to state in all caps not to release your mouse once your start drwaing your name - didn't work. Nearly 100% of my "users" (guests) are not getting it filled correctly.
the only solution I can think of that actually is workable is to just remove the feature from my form and that sort of defeats the purpose of it, doesn't it?
I'm really disappointed with Jotform's response, basically saying there's nothing wrong with their form, it's my customers who are stupid. That is not a solution - it's a cop out.
A ticket about this concern is already created. Although, the priority of that ticket is set to medium.
A workaround I can offer for this is to add a few "notes" using our "Free Text HTML" field under Power Tools. Put this field above the e-Signature field. Put some notes like "Your signature is important mainly because......."
Tried your suggestion but it doesn't work, nor do any of the other "workarounds" you've proposed, so I have removed the signature box from my forms. Please let me know when you fix the problem so that it works properly and I can reinstall it on my forms.
We'll inform you immediately as soon as this issue sorted out. We thank you for your cooperation and your patience.
Have a nice day!