What is JotForm?
JotForm is a free online form builder which helps you create online forms without writing a single line of code. No sign-up required.
At JotForm, we want to make sure that you’re getting the online form builder help that you need. Our friendly customer support team is available 24/7.
We believe that if one user has a question, there could be more users who may have the same question. This is why many of our support forum threads are public and available to be searched and viewed. If you’d like help immediately, feel free to search for a similar question, or submit your question or concern.
Unable to send replies to "Reply-to" Email when using Verified Email Address as the Sender EmailAsked by ipbr21054 on September 18, 2013 at 09:27 AM
The form in question is here.
I am not sure the customer is receiving my replies ?
The customer completes the form & i receive the form ok.
When i click on reply in my email programme i see the following
The customers name followed by (email@example.com) is this correct ?
I ask because the last 7 emails that i have replied to i do not receive a follow up email from the customers ?
Please can you check & advise thanks.
could you please trying by adding a sender address to your form email notifications:
Also could be helpful if you provide the name of the email program you are using.
please let us know if you need further assistance
I am using firefox.
Before i make any changes can you advise if my form is set up correct or not ?
You have advised me the above BUT have not advised if what you see in my form is correct or not ?
I have added the email address as mentioned above.
Please can you complete the form on the page and advise me if you receive my reply.
Please change your "Reply-to" option to the E-Mail form field, currently you have "None" selected.
This change will make it work.
Hope it helps
I have now done that.
Are the 2 fields above correct,sender name & sender email ?
yes they are, you can try by making a test submission to your form using a fake email address like "firstname.lastname@example.org" once you get the notification to your email, hit "Replay" and check if the destination address is "email@example.com"
I have done that but when i hit reply my email is shown not firstname.lastname@example.org
I've clone your form to investigate the issue and I wasn't able to replicate the issue. I am using "email@example.com" as email address on my test entry. For more information, please take a look at this video: http://www.screencast.com/t/6pyY2poPt2
Would you mind if I add my email address as form's recipient for further investigation?
No problem please continue to find the fault.
Since my previous post i have noticed that if the field Sender Email is changed to noreply@jotform then when i click on reply i then see the firstname.lastname@example.org
When Sender Email is my email address i then click on reply & it sends a reply to myself.
I have left it with noreply@jotform at the moment.
I await your reply,cheers.
You have FROM test (email@example.com)
Change this to my email firstname.lastname@example.org and then see what happens.
I ask because this is what i was told to put in the field.
In my previous post i mentioned that i got it to work by using (email@example.com)
You have just completed the form and the message is TEST.
I have clicked on reply and my email address is shown.
This is my problem.
Can you please provide us screenshot with regards on the issue that you are referring for further assistance?
With regards on my TEST entry, this is what I see after clicking REPLY: http://www.screencast.com/t/RqManpnbT
Below is a screen shot of what i see when i click on reply.
The Remote Dr "which when i send i just receive the email "
I have cloned your form and have been able to replicate the issue. It happens when the email is sent to gmail. As a test I sent it to Yahoo email and Outlook email, both of these worked properly.
I then created a new blank form and retried to have the notification to gmail, and worked. Which leads me to believe your form must be causing this somehow.
I would suggest to recreate the form as cloning replicated the problem for me. In any case I will raise a ticket so that higher level support can take a look at what caused this bug on your form.
Below I'm appending the results of your form and my blank form:
Gmail - Failed
Hotmail - worked
Yahoo - worked
My Test blank Form sent to Gmail - Passed
http://jotform.co/form/32606925487867 (you can clone it and test if you wish)
Kindly let us know if you need further assistance. Thank you
Thanks for taking a look.
At the moment when i enter NOREPLY@JOTFORM.COM in the SENDER EMAIL field it shows the customers return email address when i click on reply.
I then assume as it does this the customer will receive the reply i sent them.
I would rather have your higher support investigate my form to see why its not working as it should without me having to create a new form.
Will your support reply to this post when they look at the form with the reason why ?
If the form is working when NOREPLY@JOTFORM.COM is used is there any reason why i cant continue to use it this way at the moment ?
I can assure you that your users would receive your replies when using firstname.lastname@example.org as the Sender Email. Just please make sure to select the Email Field from your form as the "Reply-to Email".
Yes, our developers will surely notify you through this thread for any progress. No definite timeframe but I am sure that they'll look at this.
I would recommend using email@example.com while waiting for an updates from our developers. This should ensure that you are sending email replies to your users/customers.
I await the reply.
Hello 10 days have now elapsed and wondering if there is an update for this topic.
I am seeing where this issue is currently with one of our developers. As soon as there is an update you will be notified here.
I will continue to read this post
One month ago yesterday i asked about this problem.
I was told 21 days ago it was with your developer and a reply would be posted.
Please advise why it is taking so looooooooooong to sort this problem ?
When we escalate an issue to be looked into by our Development Team it then is out of our hands other then for us to check up on the problem for you since it is then up to our Development Team Members to prioritize these Issues they have recieved. It appears currently that yours has still not yet been looked into as these problems can often take some time depending on how busy our Dev Team is. We do apologize about the wait on this so I will check in with them on your behalf to see what is going on and we'll update you about it as soon as we can.
I checked this some more to try to figure this out more and I don't really think this is a problem at all. I believe that Gmail is actually detecting the differences especially when you use your own email which automatically fills in your name for you similar to " Kade " as programmed by Google. Now if there is no email found then at that point it generates a reply with only the physical email and emails domain such as " Test@test.com ".
I've noticed that when the email is used it creates two separate reply scenarios when responding to an email address of the sender email whom submitted data via the form.
Scenario A: In Scenario A the reply-to address " firstname.lastname@example.org " displays the physical email address with its domain shown as attached. See Screenshot A below and it is the same as I've depicted in your response above as well.
Scenario B: Whereas in Scenario B I used my own email aka gmail address but when replied to instead of the full gmail address with the domain shown it only populated my name instead because Gmail is smart and recognizes this. In my example below you can see it puts my name " Kade " instead of the email and it's domain. See Screenshot B below for comparison and the same is seen in yours again above as well too.
Now if you look at the NAME which google autopopulates when recognized you will then see that Google's Gmail lets you see it broken down further of where it is actually going to. I also happen to think that your Gmail Contacts List works in the same manner from what I know with this so it would happen the same way and be seen the same way for any emails that you might have added to your Contacts List thus populating those with the name too. I don't think any of this is an issue and seems to be working by Google as expected.
So the outcome of this is ?
what do i need to do ?
I would like to inform you that the issue mentioned already have a bug ticket assigned to our dev team. Unfortunatelly, we do not have news yet for updates and resolution.
Please understand that bug tickets take priority assignment depending on its impact or importance.
Currenty the priority for this is set to "Nice to do" , since it actually works when using "email@example.com" as the Sender.
If I may suggest, you can continue using the currently working option -- that is using firstname.lastname@example.org until such time the fix is available.
Please inform us if you need further assistance.
I will await an update then.
Please advise me of an update for this ticket.
I started this post in septmeber.
The last reply to this post was october.
Surely there is an update / fix by now ?
We still have this ticket open as a low priority ticket. If we be able do something about the google behaviour we will update this thread. Thanks.
This is taking way to long