Outstanding
Acceptable
Needed Work
Paper selection (importance, interest, general appeal):
Background knowledge & introduction of topic, questions, and experimental system:
Critical analysis of results:
Concise and accurate conclusions, caveats, and future experiments or implications:
Slides / visual aids: (organization, number, clarity)
Oral presentation & delivery: (Confidence, eye contact, rate of speech, enunciation, appropriate use of pauses)
Ability to answer questions from the audience:
Overall performance: