Journal Manuscript Editorial Review Report Form
Please complete this report to assess the quality and publication readiness of the submitted manuscript. Your structured feedback helps ensure the highest standards for journal publication.
Manuscript Title
*
Manuscript ID or Reference Number
*
Reviewer Name or Initials
*
Originality of the Work
*
Low
1
2
3
4
High
5
1 is Low, 5 is High
Clarity and Organization
*
Poor
1
2
3
4
Excellent
5
1 is Poor, 5 is Excellent
Soundness of Methodology
*
Unsound
1
2
3
4
Sound
5
1 is Unsound, 5 is Sound
Significance and Contribution to the Field
*
Low
1
2
3
4
High
5
1 is Low, 5 is High
Language and Writing Quality
*
Needs Improvement
1
2
3
4
Excellent
5
1 is Needs Improvement, 5 is Excellent
Strengths and Weaknesses
*
Recommendation
*
Accept
Minor Revision
Major Revision
Reject
Submit Review
Should be Empty: