Provisional Feedback Accuracy Evaluation Form
Provisional Feedback Accuracy Evaluation Form — assess how accurate and complete a piece of feedback is.
Feedback to evaluate
*
Context for evaluating this feedback
How accurate is the feedback?
*
Not at all accurate
1
2
3
4
Completely accurate
5
1 is Not at all accurate, 5 is Completely accurate
How complete is the feedback?
*
Very incomplete
1
2
3
4
Very complete
5
1 is Very incomplete, 5 is Very complete
Which aspects of the feedback did you verify?
Factual claims
Supporting evidence
Relevant context
Conclusions or recommendations
Other
Was supporting evidence available to check the feedback?
*
Yes, sufficient evidence
Some evidence
No evidence available
Not applicable
What important information, if any, is missing?
Are any parts unclear or difficult to verify?
Overall, how reliable is this feedback?
*
1
2
3
4
5
Additional observations
Submit evaluation
Should be Empty: